Practicality of enforcing revised BWSSB STP norms for existing apartment complexes

285

Written By murali772 - 6 September, 2016

Bangalore Water Media Reports Storm Water Drains Rain water harvesting BWSSB, sewage treatment plants sewage management pollution control board

The Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board (BWSSB) has extended the deadline for installation of sewage treatment plant (STPs) in domestic and non-domestic buildings till October end.

In case of domestic building if the owner, occupier or the builder fails to provide the facility in the stipulated period an additional penalty of 25% of water and sanitary charges levied for the first three months from November 2016 to January 2017. And thereafter, the penalty will be 50% of water and sanitary charges till the installation of the facility.

- - - Earlier this year, a BWSSB notification dated February 25, 2016 had set July 2016 as the deadline for domestic buildings to comply by the STP norm and for non-domestic buildings, October 2016 was the deadline. Sources in the BWSSB said the Board has extended the deadline as many buildings in the city are yet to abide by the norm.

The BWSSB has also relaxed the STP norms according to which any owner or occupier or builder who construct/constructed any structure consisting of 20 or more houses or apartments or flats having a total built up area of 2000 Sq mtrs and above including basement within the jurisdiction of BWSSB shall provide STP or Grey Water Treatment Plant (GWTP) with in their premises. The norm earlier was 100 sq mtrs and lot of residents had expressed opposition for the same. However, there has been no change made to the rule which calls for dual piping system for toilet flushing purpose in the buildings.

- - - The norms further say that in all the above mentioned cases treated water from STP should be used for toilet flushing and for other non-potable purposes. BWSSB will give water supply connection to the above category buildings based on the consent for Establishment issued by KSPCB under Environment Act 1074.


For the full text of the report in the ToI, dt 9th Aug, 2016, click here.

On seeing the report, I had thought that it would apply only to new projects, and not the ones that had been commissioned long back. However, a few days back, the services manager of the apartment complex, where I reside, brought to my attention the letters received from BWSSB asking us too to conform to the revised norms, before October end.

Now, I live in an apartment complex in Koramangala, with 124 units, having an aggregate SBA (super built-up area) of close to 25,000 sqM, whose largely norms-compliant "Occupancy Certificate" was issued in 2004. With under-ground sewage lines already available in the area, all that the builder had to do was to connect up our sewage line to the BWSSB mains, outside our gates, quite as per the approval granted. And, from then on, we have been availing the facility and paying the "sanitary charges" too, which is now totalling to a colossal two-thirds of our water bill, including for the borewell water.

Every other facility in the complex has also been architectured according to the norms prevalent then. As such, retro-fitting fresh facilities like an STP, treated water supply lines to each apartment (and the equipment that go along-with them), etc, is a near impossible task now. On the "Rain-water harvesting" front too, there are limitations to what an existing complex can achieve; what can be done, has already been done.

The fear now is that BWSSB is going to be letting loose an "inspector-raaj", essentially for the rent-seeking lot amongst them to make merry.

I expect many other apartment complexes (particularly those within the earlier Corporation limits) are also faced with the same problem. The point in my publishing this blog is to start a debate amongst the affected lot on how to tackle this issue, collectively.

I'll be requesting Mr Sridhar Pabbisetty, CEO of Namma Bengaluru Foundation, and Convener of BRACE, to include it in the agenda for the next monthy meet too.

Meanwhile, comments from readers are most welcome.

Muralidhar Rao

PS: This is in addition to BWSSB's inequitus levies on apartment complexes for its services - check here, for that.

COMMENTS


can have only prospective effect

murali772 - 17 October, 2016 - 09:43

Incidentally, going by the contents of the GoK notification dt 19/01/16, accessible here, it becomes amply clear that the CPCB has envisaged providing of captive STP's for residential complexes commissioned only subsequent to the issuance of their notification no A-19014/41/2006-MON/1242 dt 22/05/15, cited in the GoK notification. This has apparently been corroborated by a senior KPSCB official too when the matter was referred to him, though orally.

As such, for complexes already connected to the BWSSB sewage lines well before 22/05/15, the question of providing a captive STP does not arise. If the BWSSB insists, perhaps the matter has to be challenged in the courts.

BWSSB chairman Tushar Giri Nath told TOI that he was helpless since the directives were issued by the environment department.

"When the directives were issued, I sought clarification on whether they were applicable to existing buildings as well.The department said they were, which meant our hands were tied," he added.


For the full text (emphasis added by me) of the report in the ToI, click here.

Perhaps the Environment ministry higher ups could be talked to, failing which the option can only be the approach to the judiciary.

The question of why captive STP's when there's supposed to be a centralised sewage system is another debate, for which perhaps another blog could be started.

In one's own perspective,  -

depending on the facts and circumstances obtainng in a case to case basis, and pending the final outcome of possible steps / action against BWSSB under discussion, the aggrieved, as a class, may have to prudently keep open the option to try and have recourse to the promoters/sellers, to be recompensed if and when that situation arises.

Wiith that in mind, perhaps, it might be equally prudent to get and have the promoters/sellers , and /or its represetaive body being, CREDAI, actively involved,  even at the present stage of  dicussions with the authorities.

Suggestive Feedback Inputs have been shared on Facebook and Linkedin.

Timeline : Venkataraman Swaminathan

Apartment-level Wastewater Treatment & Reuse in Bangalore:
Research Dissemination and Discussion Meeting
Organized by
Ashoka Trust for Research in Ecology and the Environment
Date: 5th November 2016
Venue: Raheja Residency Club House, Koramangala
9:30 – 10:00 Registration
10:00 – 10:15 Introducing the workshop and participant self-introduction

SESSION I: Economic, Regulatory and Policy Issues
10:15 – 10:45 Economic and institutional factors
influencing apartment level waste-water
reuse
Dr. Sharachchandra Lele &
Pradeep Kuttuva (ATREE)
10:45 – 11:15
Expert perspectives
Mr. Ramakrishna, Chief Engineer,
BWSSB (tbc)
Mr. Shivalinge Gowda, SEO,
KSPCB (tbc)
Mr. MDN Simha, Retd. Chief
Environmental Officer, KSPCB
11:15 – 11:45 Open Discussion

SESSION II: Technological Issues
11:45 – 12:15 Technological assessment of apartment-level
STPs
Dr. Priyanka Jamwal (ATREE)
12:15 – 12:45 Expert perspectives Dr. Ananth Kodavasal
Mr. Nagesh Aras
12:45 – 13:15 Open Discussion
13:15 – 13:30 SUMMING UP Dr. Sharachchandra Lele

RSVP: Pradeep Kuttuwa (Mob: 94488 72052 / Email: pradeep.kuttuva@gmail.com). The club hall has limited capacity, and therefore, prior registration is a must (except for invitees)

relevant BWSSB circular

murali772 - 30 September, 2016 - 13:26

The BWSSB circular dt 03/03/16 pertaining to the subject is accessible here.


PRAJA.IN COMMENT GUIDELINES

Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!