Bengaluru CRS - RITES Final Report

0

Written By kbsyed61 - 11 November, 2012

Bangalore Commuter rail

Courtesy, Directorate of Urban Land Transport (DULT), here is the copy of the RITES final report that submitted to the DULT. You would remember that In June/July, RITES had submitted the draft report which was deliberated upon by all the stakeholders including the "Praja-RAAG". Per DULT, this is the final version of the report based on the feedback from DULT, and SWR.

This report is avilable on DULT website - http://www.urbantransport.kar.gov.in/Bangalore_CRS_Final_Report.pdf

On behalf of Praja, a Big thanks to RITES for bringing out this wonderful report endorsing the need for CRS in Bengaluru backed up by data. This has certainly boosted the CRS chances this time.

Based on my first reading of this report (Though bulk of the content hasn't changed), here are the notable updates of Final Version:

Suggested Phases of the CRS

 

Phase -1 Routes ----> SBC/Yeshwantpur to Tumkur, Chickballapur and Hosur.

Phase - 2 Routes ---> To Bangarpet, Mandya,  and Dodballapur.

 

Per this report,

"...Apart from the above cited issues, phasing of investments and corresponding benefits to the public are also important considerations while deciding the phases. Client advised that they had deliberated among their officials and desired to keep TK, CBP and HSRA sections under Phase 1 and balance in phase 2. Accordingly, total proposed investment is recommended in 3 phases.

  • Phase 1: To tackle sections where the commuter demand is high i.e. constituting about Two Thirds of total demand.
  • Phase 2: To tackle all balance sections.
  • Phase 3: To introduce additional halts on CRS network and to increase EMU rake lengths from 9 car to 15 cars.

CRS Frequency

 

Phase - 1Highlights

  1. Procurement of 5 MEMU rakes.
  2. Making SBC – BNC into twin single line and BNC – BYPL into automatic signalling or IBs.
  3. Implementation of Commuter Rail System for Bangalore Final Report (August 2012)
  4. DULT Government of Karnataka 105 RITES
  5. Development of 4 pit lines at BYPLN.
  6. Development of 2 additional pit lines at YPR.
  7. Estimated Cost: Rs 3831 Crores.
  8. Time Frame: About 3 years from date of sanction by IR. However, where doubling already exists (SBC-YPR-TK), CRS can be implemented in 2 years.
  9. Potential for additional Services: 330 services.
  10. Additional Services proposed to be introduced considering the demand: 172.

Phase 2 Highlights

  1. In this phase, it is recommended to take up all remaining sections for full-fledged implementation of CRS in Bangalore.
  2. Estimated Cost: Rs. 2251 Crores
  3. Time Frame: About 2 years from date of sanction by IR. However where doubling already exists (SBC-BWT, SBC-MYA and YNK-BYPL), CRS can be implemented in 2 years.
  4. Potential for additional services: 320 Services.
  5. Additional Services proposed to be introduced considering the demand: 94.
  6. Estimated to cater for: 38% of estimated rail commuter demand in 2021.

Phase 3 Highlights

  1. This phase is for making use of the up graded infrastructure for serving more and more public by introducing additional halts in the CRS network and by increasing the length of EMU rakes and removing further finer bottlenecks.
  2. Thus, it is recommended to increase the length of EMU rakes to 12 rakes and to 15 rakes keeping the same number of services and to develop additional halts in CRS network.

 

COMMENTS


Long hard report... seems to

sanjayv - 11 November, 2012 - 12:15

Long hard report... seems to be full of repetition as well.  GoK has to look at this as an opportunity to upgrade the rail network around B'lore and leverage the rail network to make the city and surrounds more livable. They need to

1. Focus on Phase Ia and I

2. Decide on how much money they can put down, type of SPV

3. Do some homework on other aspects - Land, potential ameneties that can be provided, future station locations, need for RUBs, ROBs, intermodal connectivity etc. and start provisioning for that.

4.Political buy in... They have to go to GoI and be willing to let GoI/Congress share credit. Very hard for this to fly otherwise.  You can ask questions on various aspects till kingdom come.

 

what abt Bangarapete?

srinidhi - 19 November, 2012 - 06:44

wonder why they dropped  bangarpete from the first list...as we know its the most promising route and the existing user base is also good..this along with the Thumakuru line are the most active ones as of today..

guess the argument is that these lines are already busy and 'lines are not free'!

But still think we will need to include  Bangarpete for the first experiment..we can park Chikkaballapura for later implementations

Anyways its a good start!

No reason if a project based on these kind of faulty DPRs fails.

I feel...that this will head no where...with the current political scenario....I feel nothing is gonna happen to CRS. absolute political will is missing. Govt - the kind of involvement it shows to Namma Metro - the same Govt. fails in CRS. lets hope atleast they start Mandya/Hosur lines at the earliest...

Regards

kamal

 

 

Interesting, to start with, SWR seems to prefer CRS services to Tumkur, Hosur and chickballapur. Not a bad idea, provided there is parallel works undertaken for complete CRS network.

Schedule of 10-20 Mins during Peak/Non-Peak hrs seems to match with our recommendations. Not a bad proposition at all.


PRAJA.IN COMMENT GUIDELINES

Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!